Former
Olympus chief executive tells of risks he ran in exposing fraud scandal at the
digital camera company
The Guardian, Rupert Neate, Friday 23 November 2012
![]() |
| Michael Woodford got wind of the allegations of fraud worth over £1bn just weeks after taking over as CEO at Olympus. Photograph: Graham Turner for the Guardian |
"This
is humbling. It's a long way from a private jet," Michael Woodford shouts
out as he charges across five lanes of traffic and into the underground at
Euston Square.
![]() |
Exposure :
Inside the Olympus
Scandal – How I Went from
CEO to Whistleblower
by Michael Woodford
|
In a
previous life as the boss of one of Japan's biggest companies, Woodford was
used to being served champagne at 33,000ft as a stewardess put slippers on his
feet. But that was a very different life again from the one Woodford was born
into, in a "sink estate in Liverpool".
As well as
having a difficult upbringing in a "shoebox"-sized home, Woodford was
bullied for being both Jewish and Chinese – he is neither, but he went to the
King David Jewish school and has a slightly oriental appearance from Tamil
ancestry.
"To
get home you had to walk past the two big rough comprehensives, and they'd see
my school blazer and yellow and black tie and they'd say, 'Are you a yid, lad?'
"I
would say, 'No, I'm a gentile,' but they couldn't understand that, which would
always irritate them and I'd get pushed around. Another day I'd come back and
they'd say, 'Are you a chink, lad?'. I'd say, 'No I'm English,' and they'd say,
'Ah, two number 16s.' They thought they were hilarious."
Despite the
bullying, Woodford, 52, is still in touch with many friends from his formative
years in Liverpool and Southend. But he says you will never catch him boasting
about the private jet that would whisk him from the modest Southend home he has
lived in for 30 years to Paris for the overnight first-class flight to Tokyo,
or his £2.75m to £3m a year salary. "My friends aren't businessmen,
they're artists and teachers, that sort of thing," he says. "If I
went on about things like that, they would think I was a tosser."
While he
always tried to stay grounded as he climbed the corporate ladder at Olympus
over three decades, it's tough, he says, to break ties with the luxury
lifestyle. "I don't like travelling economy on long-haul flights. All that
pampering over the years has obviously got to me – so it's always business
class," he says as he relaxes into the leather seats of the first-class
carriage from Paddington to Oxford for the latest in a series of public
speaking engagements.
Woodford
joined Olympus's British subsidiary Keymed as a salesman in 1980 and rose to
become managing director of the division before he was 30, then went on to
become head of Olympus in Europe before being called to the top job in Japan.
"But, you know, I don't live on a yacht or do silly things."
It's not as
if he can't afford to be a little silly. Earlier this year he collected a £10m
settlement over his dismissal for blowing the whistle on a £1bn fraud scandal
at the endoscope and digital camera company.
"It
must make you feel sick, interviewing people earning all this money," he
says. "I'm quite leftwing, you know. I could be a communist, if that
worked any better than capitalism."
Some of his
beliefs would go down well with Marx and Lenin. His kids won't be getting any
of the £10m. "If I'm struck down now, they won't get a penny," he
says. "Rather than being posh little rich kids, they're going to go out
there and earn it on their own." Edward, 19, and Isabel, 17, were sent to
state grammar schools until he left for Tokyo, when Isabel was sent to a
private boarding school – "she would have had to be sedated and handcuffed
to go [to Tokyo]" – where, Woodford says, she's educating her classmates.
"Isabel
told me the other day that some of her friends at school were saying taxation
is wrong – not the level of taxation [but the fact that it exists]. She told
them that that's what pays for the hospitals and the schools for other kids who
can't afford to go to nice little rich schools."
His money
will go to charity, predominantly those campaigning for human rights, such as
Clive Stafford-Smith's Reprieve, and road safety foundations.
Noting the
irony that he had just run across one of London's busiest junctions, he says,
"But we looked both ways, right? And we were late. Being late in Japan is
just about the rudest thing you can do. The contents of a meeting [in Japan]
don't matter as long as you arrive on time."
Woodford
says Japan's obsession with politeness and social niceties is partly to blame
for the country's fall from the top of the global power tree and the fraud that
almost destroyed the 93-year-old Japanese electronics company.
"There
is a disaster in Japan because of these social characteristics – the deference,
not being able to question people in authority," he says. It was this
attitude, he continues, that almost allowed Olympus's previous bosses to cover
up more than £1bn of fraud.
He first
got wind of the claims just weeks after taking over as chief executive – the
first foreigner, or gaijin, to run the company, and only the fourth at any
major Japanese company – when a friend emailed him a translation of
"amazingly detailed" claims published in Facta, a local magazine with
a campaigning remit similar to Private Eye.
"When
I got to the office I expected everyone to be talking about it. But no one
mentioned it." By lunchtime he summoned two of his most trusted colleagues
and ask them if they had read it. They had, but said that Tsuyoshi Kikukawa,
Olympus's previous CEO and then chairman, had "told them not to tell
me". Eventually Woodford demanded a meeting with Kikukawa and Hisashi
Mori, then deputy president and "Kikukawa's permanent sidekick".
The table
for the lunchtime meeting was set out with the "most wonderful selection
of sushi, but in front of my place was a tuna sandwich", Woodford, a
committed sushi fan, told students at Saïd business school in Oxford later that
evening. "It wasn't just any tuna sandwich – it was a tuna sandwich that
would have made British Rail in 1981 proud. It was that manky. The tuna
sandwich was to tell me my place in life.
"That's
when it really blew up, and the shit hit the fan," he said, before pausing
hand over mouth in mock horror that he might have committed another terrible
faux pas on top of arriving half an hour late for his own talk. "Can you
say that at Oxford?"
Although
Woodford tried to embarrass Mori into talking to him by following him into the
urinals and shouting at him eyeball to eyeball, Mori and Kikukawa refused to
explain why Olympus had spent almost £1bn buying three "Mickey Mouse"
companies and paid $687m for mergers and acquisitions (M&A) advice on the
deal. "It was the largest payment ever made for M&A advice in the history
of capitalism by a factor of three," Woodford says. Forensic accountants
traced the money to London, from where it "went to the Cayman Islands and
disappeared".
When the
next edition of Facta was published, it claimed the fraud was linked to
"antisocial forces" – code for the Yakuza, the Japanese mafia.
"I was scared. Even telling you now I can feel myself shaking and feel my
hands going cold, soon my feet will go cold too," he says. "I started
to think what was going to happen to me. My fate could have been, 'Michael has
been under a lot of stress, he's been drinking and taking sleeping pills. He
jumped off the top of a building.' That's what happens in Japan."
At home,
his wife, Nuncy, ("she's Spanish, Latin-tempered and very bossy") was
having constant nightmares. And it was about to get worse. Woodford called a
meeting of the whole Olympus board to discuss the crisis, but Kikukawa had
changed the agenda. "This meeting is to vote on the dismissal of Michael
Woodford as CEO," Woodford heard via simultaneous translation in his
headset. "As he said the O, all the directors put their arms up. They
couldn't have put them up higher."
The next
word was from Kikukawa. "'Mr Woodford cannot speak on this matter because
he has a conflict of interest.' It was an eight-minute corporate
execution."
He was
forced to give up his apartment and take the bus to the airport, but Woodford
wouldn't acquiesce to Mori's demands to hand over his iPhone. "I got in
his face. 'Are you going to take it off me? My wife will be phoning, she'll be
worried,'" he says. "Mr Mori didn't know I'd grown up in
Liverpool."
Within
hours he had given all the details to the press and the police. Kikukawa and
Mori eventually resigned, but even then the rest of the board and institutional
shareholders failed to support his bid to be reinstated as CEO.
"It is
like a John Grisham novel. But it's true."
Exposure:
Inside the Olympus Scandal – How I Went from CEO to Whistleblower (Portfolio
Penguin) is published on 29 November. Available for £16 from
www.guardianbookshop.co.uk
Related Article:


No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.